Monday, June 11, 2012

Some Thoughts on Location and the Law of Non-contradiction


By Ben Russell

If an unbeliever asserts that contradictions can occur because water, grass, rocks, and material things can exist at more than one location at one time simply point out that it is not the case because the properties that make up each individual object are in their own location in space. For example, with the compound water each molecule is made up of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom and each individual atom takes up only one specific location in space (regardless of their size) but those exact specific molecules can't be in the same location as of another location within a single nano second in time which explains why you can have water in more than one location (such as California and China for example) except its billions of molecules of the compound water that is mixed together. That also works with grass, rocks, wood, anything in the universe that is made of matter that does not have a mind or life based functions (people, animals, etc.) Plants are not alive from a biblical perspective (unlike the perspective of many modern day Americans). Accordingly, in the biblical sense--plants, grass, trees, etc. can individually be multiplied at more than one location at a time (such as France and America for example) because of the Bible's definition of what "life" is. We have no scientific based evidence that our specific DNA, mind, soul, spirit, will, etc. exists outside of our current and individual locations. Saying that there is no evidence against such an assertion would commit the logical fallacy called "appear to ignorance." In fact it would break the law of non-contradiction if exact selves of our individual selves were also placed outside anywhere of our current exact locations (such as two feet away, country away, planet away, etc.) but in the Christian worldview we know it is impossible.
------------------------------

Mr. Russell is an apologist in training. You may contact him through this web site or leave a comment.

No comments:

Post a Comment